Security

My Two-Step Verification Order: Passkeys First

Passkeys first, YubiKeys for the accounts that hold money, 2FAS for the rest, and backup codes in Bitwarden. The order I follow every time.

LPLP
Security
In this article

The short version

  • I turn on a passkey first, on every account that offers one.
  • For money and other serious accounts, the passkey goes on two YubiKeys: a main one and a copy.
  • For everything else, the passkey lives in Bitwarden or on my computer.
  • Codes that change every 30 seconds go in 2FAS. Backup codes go in Bitwarden.
  • For a team of five, I would split the backup codes in equal parts, one part each.

Two-step verification sounds like one thing. In my setup it is three, and I try them in the same order every time.

What do I turn on first?

A passkey. If the site lets me create one, I do it before I look at any other option. I wrote about how keys and passkeys differ in Security Keys vs Passkeys: What I Use and Where, so here I only care about the order.

Which accounts get a YubiKey?

I ask one question: does this account touch money or something very serious? If the answer is yes, I create the passkey on my YubiKey, and then again on the second one. Two keys, same account. One of them can get lost and I still walk in with the other.

Passkey first, and everything else behind it.

If the answer is no, I create the passkey in Bitwarden or on the computer itself. It opens faster and, for what those accounts hold, it is secure enough for me.

What is the second path?

Some sites do not offer passkeys. For those I use the codes that change every 30 seconds, and they live in 2FAS, an open-source app. When a site hands me backup codes, they go to Bitwarden, saved with the account they belong to.

How could five people share this?

I have never run this inside a company, so this is what I would do and not a report. The backup codes can be split in equal parts, one part for each of the five people, so everyone has some in case they need them. When someone leaves, those codes are cancelled and new ones are created. The rest of that story is in When Someone Leaves the Team, Reset Everything.

This is my experience, not security advice. Features and plans change, so check each provider.