Data

Not All Recurring Revenue Is Good Revenue

MRR says nothing about which agreements are worth keeping. A simple quarterly margin check per agreement shows where to reprice or rescope.

LPLP
Data
In this article

The short version

  • A small group of agreements carries a company’s profit while a few quietly consume it.
  • A flat fee is a bet on how much work the customer will need.
  • Measure revenue, direct labor, tools and licensing, then margin, for every agreement each quarter.
  • At the bottom of the list, options are reprice, rescope, stabilize the environment or part ways.

MSP owners love monthly recurring revenue, and for good reason. It smooths cash flow, supports valuations, and makes hiring decisions easier. But MRR is a top-line number. It says nothing about whether each dollar of it is worth keeping.

In most managed services businesses, a small group of agreements carries the profitability of the whole company, while a few others quietly consume it. The second group is usually not obvious from the income statement, because the total still looks healthy.

What hides inside a flat-fee agreement

A flat monthly fee is a bet: the provider agrees to deliver an uncertain amount of work for a certain price. Some customers use exactly what was expected. Others generate twice the tickets, require after-hours support, run aging hardware that breaks constantly, or keep adding users without updating the agreement. The revenue line stays flat while the cost line grows.

How to measure it

Agreement-level profitability does not require a perfect cost accounting system. A reasonable approach:

  1. Revenue: the monthly agreement amount plus any related billable work.
  2. Direct labor: hours logged against the customer, multiplied by a loaded hourly cost for technicians.
  3. Tools and licensing: per-seat or per-device costs for software and services bundled into the agreement.
  4. Margin: revenue minus those costs, expressed as a percentage.

Run that calculation quarterly for every agreement and sort the results. The bottom of the list is where the conversation starts.

What to do with the results

An unprofitable agreement is not automatically a bad customer. It may be underpriced, under-scoped, or overdue for a price adjustment. It may reflect an environment that needs a project to stabilize it. Or it may simply be a relationship that no longer fits the business model.

The options are usually: reprice, rescope, invest in stabilizing the environment, or, in some cases, part ways respectfully. Each is a business decision. None of them is possible without the data.

The broader point

Revenue growth is easy to celebrate and easy to report. Margin quality takes more work to see. For finance leaders in the MSP space, one of the most valuable things we can offer is moving the conversation from “how much do we bill?” to “how much do we keep, and from whom?”

Written by
CFO | Finance & Accounting Leader
LP Official Author of LedgerPost since 2026 · Founding Author No. 3

Gabriel J. Denny is a CFO and a finance and accounting leader. He writes about finance operations in managed service providers.