When Your Music Distributor Pulls Your Catalog
Our EP vanished, a copy resurfaced from inside the distributor, and about 2 million streams went with it. How we got the catalog back, and what to check first.
In this article
The short version
- Our distributor took an EP down, and a copy of it later resurfaced from inside the distributor’s own platform.
- Song titles changed to English in the stores. That created new copies and cost about 2 million streams.
- Lawyers need a defendant. We had none to name, so the fix came from distribution, not from the courts.
- Before you need help, check that your distributor has a real person you can talk to.
At the end of July, an EP I manage disappeared from every streaming platform. The artist is not famous. Keep that in mind, because it is the point of this article.
Our distributor had notified us of a copyright claim and pulled the release. We had seven days to appeal. I appealed the same day, with the copyright registrations for all five recordings attached. In my dashboard the EP showed as withdrawn, and I could not upload it again. The reason I was given: a copy already existed on their servers. I never learned who had filed the claim.
Who put the EP back online?
Spotify support did, in a sense. One of their advisers showed me proof that the EP had been uploaded again from inside the same distributor’s platform. Not from my account. My dashboard still said withdrawn.
I had no written answer from the distributor on any of this. I only had my dashboard, and nobody else had access beyond it.
What did it cost us?
Some songs also lost their play counts. Their titles had switched to English in the stores. I never made that change, and the only party with access beyond my dashboard was the distributor. The English titles created new copies that started at zero. The old copies, the ones sitting in playlists, turned gray and stopped playing.
Across the songs we lost about 2 million streams. The gray playlist entries cost another 15,000 to 20,000 streams a month. Fans kept asking me why a song had dropped so hard.
Streams are the number the industry reads. Our new distributor moved us from artist to label account partly because of ours. Pitches, playlists and offers follow from that count, so losing it hit the business directly.
Why did the legal route go nowhere?
We spent close to a month looking for legal help. Every lawyer asked the same question: who is the other party?
No defendant, no case.
The distributor never said who had filed the claim. According to the person who later helped us, the other party was the distributor itself. So there was nobody to sue.
Support was no better. In about four hours, Spotify passed me through six advisers. The distributor’s support took about three hours and roughly seven advisers, and they contradicted each other. Ask a precise question and you get transferred.
What finally fixed it?
A contact who works with several distributors, and who had stopped using ours after earlier problems like this one.
By early October our music was with Symphonic. We took down everything from the old distributor. Then I filed a copyright claim on the EP with Spotify, as the project’s manager, using the registrations from Colombia’s copyright office. The office itself did nothing for us. Spotify needed that paperwork to act. On October 8, the old distributor deleted its copy. The streams and the playlists came back as they were.
Being a label changes more than the name. Symphonic lets us send ad pitches to platforms few people can reach, run sub-labels with simple splits for several artists, and automate payments. An artist account gets none of that.
What should you check before you need it?
Find out whether you can reach a real person at your distributor. Not a ticket form. A person. If you have no contract and no contact, move to a distributor that gives you either. Do not choose one because it belongs to a big platform or because a famous name uses it.
Keep your registrations and papers current. And do not decide your project is too small for this to happen. Ours was small.
This is my experience, not legal advice. Copyright and distribution rules vary by country and by contract.
