Security

Why I Keep My Passwords in Two Password Managers

Bitwarden as the main, Proton Pass as the backup, 24-character passwords and a secret ending kept out of both apps. The mistake that led me here.

LPLP
Security
In this article

The short version

  • Every password is generated by a manager and is at least 24 characters, and I add a short ending that I never store in any app.
  • Bitwarden is my main manager and Proton Pass is my backup. I move the data across by hand every few days.
  • My two-step codes live in a separate app, not in the managers.
  • I once used one easy password everywhere. A leak at another company took my accounts down one by one.

For years I used the same email address and the same password everywhere. Short, easy to type, easy to remember. I figured nobody would bother with me.

What mistake started all this?

A big platform got hacked. It made the news around the world, and the stolen data included usernames and passwords. I never read past the headline. You think it won’t happen to you.

Then the services I had signed up for with that email and that password started falling, one by one. My guess is that someone took the stolen pairs and tried them on other sites. I never confirmed it. I can’t even tell you which platform it was, because it was years ago.

That is when I decided to use passwords so strong that I couldn’t know them myself.

Why do I use two password managers?

Bitwarden is my main one. I have used it for many years, and it was the first manager I ever tried. It works well in the apps and in the browser extensions. A few times I have even been a beta tester.

Proton Pass is my backup.

Why two? Things go wrong. I trust Bitwarden a lot, and I still keep a copy. A saying I like: don’t trust, verify.

Every few days I export my vault from Bitwarden and import it into Proton Pass. The transfer is simple. I don’t know whether the two can sync on their own, so I do it by hand. One warning: a standard export is a readable file. I delete it as soon as the import finishes.

Don’t trust, verify.

What rules do I follow?

Every password is at least 24 characters, symbols included. The manager generates it. I never make one up.

Then I do one more thing. The generated password is not the one I log in with. At the end of every password I add five or six characters that are not stored in any app or note. If someone got into Bitwarden or Proton Pass, the passwords they found would still be missing that ending. Some people call it a pepper. I also have a way back if I ever forget it, with people I trust. Without that, forgetting it would lock me out of everything.

It sounds like a chore. It is a few extra keystrokes. I add it at the end because after autofill the cursor is already there. At the start I would have to move it every time.

My two-step verification codes are in 2FAS, an open source app, and not in the password managers. I also use physical security keys, which deserve their own article.

What happens if I lose my phone?

I have this ready. I sign in to Bitwarden from another device, then close every session I can: Bitwarden, Proton, everything else. Even if someone got to the vaults, the passwords would not be enough to log in, because the ending is not in them.

How do I share a password with someone?

With Proton Pass, mostly because I like how it looks. It takes a couple of clicks. You send a link, choose when it expires and limit how many times it can be opened. Set a low number of views and it stops working once they are used.

I have never used a team plan, only personal ones. They have worked very well, but I have not tested a team plan, so I won’t recommend one. For a team, what I would try first is simple: stop sending passwords over WhatsApp or in a spreadsheet, and send a one-use link.

The alias covers your email address. This covers the other half.

This is my experience, not security advice. Features and plans change, so check each provider.