Security

Security Keys vs Passkeys: What I Use and Where

Two YubiKeys for the accounts that touch money, passkeys in Bitwarden for the rest, and the risk of signing in with a key alone.

LPLP
Security
In this article

The short version

  • I carry two YubiKey security keys, a main one and a spare, registered on the same accounts.
  • I use them on accounts that touch money, payments or other people’s work. Passkeys saved in Bitwarden cover the less important ones.
  • Some sites accept a key as the only login. If someone knows where you are registered and holds your key, that is a risk, so add a second step where you can.
  • For a team of five, I would start with one key per person.

Passwords came first in my setup. Keys came later, for the accounts where a break-in would hurt the most.

Which keys do I use, and how do they work?

I use YubiKeys. Someone who knows a lot about security recommended them more than any other brand. I looked at the options myself afterwards, and these were the ones that convinced me. Mine connect by USB-A and also have NFC. I have two, identical.

What I do at login depends on the platform. On one I use a lot, the page just says to sign in with a passkey. I click it, insert the key, and touch the metal sensor on it with my finger. That is the whole login. Mine are touch keys, not fingerprint ones. Some YubiKey models do read fingerprints, but mine don’t. Both keys have a PIN set, which adds a barrier if someone gets hold of one. Other platforms ask for a username and a password first, and then use the key as a second step. It works the same way.

On a phone, I hold the key against it and NFC does the rest. On a computer with no NFC, I plug the key into the USB-A port and touch the sensor.

Where do I use them?

On accounts that touch money. The ones where I get paid, where I keep savings, and where I look after other people’s work, like the platforms that distribute music. Nothing has given me trouble so far. Some platforms don’t support passkeys yet. More do every time I check.

What is the difference between a key and a passkey in Bitwarden?

I also keep passkeys in Bitwarden, and the difference for me is access. The physical key is there the second I need it, by NFC or USB. With a passkey in Bitwarden I need my device, my master password and my face. It is a little more trouble.

So I use the Bitwarden ones for accounts that are not so important. They are also what I always have with me when I don’t have my keys.

Is a passkey-only login risky?

Yes. Some sites let you sign in with the key alone. If someone knows which platforms you are registered on, holds your key, and the site accepts a passkey as the only step, that is a risk. A PIN on the key helps, so set one.

Where the site offers it, add two-step verification on top of the key.

What would a team of five do?

One key for each of the five, at the minimum. A spare for each person is better. The other option is a single spare kept where everyone knows to look for it, easy to reach and quick to get. Anyone who can reach it can use it, so choose the place with care.

I would start with the accounts that hold money or other people’s work. Those are the ones that cost the most if they fall.

The passwords behind all of this are in Why I Keep My Passwords in Two Password Managers, and the full setup I would give a small team is in Small Business Security Setup: What I Use Every Day.

This is my experience, not security advice. Features and plans change, so check each provider.