MSP

The predictable business with unpredictable books

Managed service providers sell certainty to their clients. Many have surprisingly little of it about their own margins.

LPLP
MSP
In this article

The short version

  • Most MSPs run three businesses through one revenue line, and the blended gross margin describes none of them.
  • Agreements bill in advance and licenses bill in arrears, so a month’s margin is partly fiction until cost and revenue are matched by agreement.
  • A monthly match of cost to revenue by agreement, product and sales order catches more leakage than a variance report.
  • Sales tax on managed services depends on the state. Someone has to own that calendar.

The pitch of a managed service provider (MSP) is reassuringly dull. For a fixed monthly fee per user or per device, it will keep a firm’s laptops patched, its servers backed up and its email out of the hands of fraudsters. Clients like the predictability. Buyers like it too, and in the deals I have seen they pay for recurring revenue.

Open the books of a typical small or mid-sized provider, though, and predictability is in short supply. Revenue lands in the wrong month. Costs arrive a month late. Hardware resale swells the top line and flatters growth while doing little for profit. Ask the owner what the gross margin is on managed services, separate from everything else, and the honest answer is often a shrug.

The cause is the business model. It has three features that ordinary small-business accounting handles poorly.

Why does a blended gross margin mislead?

Most MSPs I have worked with are really three businesses sharing a bank account. There is the recurring service, which is high-margin and labor-intensive. There is resale of third-party licenses, such as Microsoft 365 or security software, which is low-margin and almost entirely cost of goods. And there is project and hardware work, which is lumpy and moves cash in large chunks. Lumped into a single revenue line, the three produce a gross margin that describes none of them.

An illustrative month for a provider with roughly $250,000 in monthly billings shows how much the blend can hide:

Revenue stream (illustrative)RevenueDirect costGross margin
Managed services (agreements)$140,000$56,00060%
License resale$60,000$51,00015%
Hardware and projects$50,000$40,00020%
Blended$250,000$147,00041%

These figures are made up to show the mechanics. They are not benchmarks.

A blended 41% looks respectable. It also hides that a quarter of the revenue earns 15%, and that a month with a large hardware order will push the headline margin down even though the core business has not changed at all. Owners who manage to the blended figure end up chasing the wrong problems.

Why does the monthly close drift?

Timing. In the setups I have seen, agreements are billed in advance, on the first of the month, through a professional services automation (PSA) platform such as ConnectWise. Licensing suppliers, especially distributors, tend to bill in arrears for consumption already incurred. So January’s revenue sits beside December’s license costs, and any month in which seat counts change produces a gross-margin figure that is partly fiction.

The PSA adds to the difficulty. In the ConnectWise-to-QuickBooks setups I have worked with, a recurring agreement, its mid-month additions, a one-off sales order and the procurement of the hardware behind it are separate objects, each with its own dates and billing status. When they sync into QuickBooks, they arrive as invoices dated when they were generated, not when the service was delivered. An invoice for a prorated addition in late March can be dated April 2. A sales order invoiced in installments can carry a date that matches neither the order nor the shipment. Month-end close at an MSP is, to a surprising degree, the work of putting each invoice back in the period it belongs to and finding the cost that goes with it.

My fix is to match cost to revenue at the level where they are actually linked: the agreement, the product and the sales order, not the account. Where revenue for a product exists without its cost, or cost without revenue, there is either an unbilled service or an unrecorded bill. Run monthly, this one exercise has caught more leakage in my clients’ books than any number of variance analyses on the profit and loss account.

Which taxes catch MSPs out?

Managed IT services sit in a gray zone of American sales-tax law. In my experience some states tax software and digital services, some tax certain IT services, and many treat a bundle of taxable and non-taxable elements by rules that differ in detail from one statehouse to the next. Picture a provider in one state with clients in two others. It can face three different answers to the question of what is taxable in a monthly agreement that includes licenses, monitoring and help-desk time.

Getting this wrong is expensive in a particular way. Sales tax that was never collected from customers is still owed by the provider, and it is hard to recover from clients years later. Payroll taxes add their own traps. I have seen state unemployment registrations lapse, quarterly returns go unfiled during a change of payroll provider, and a small penalty notice turn into a lien. None of this is exotic. It is small administrative facts that nobody owns.

Sales-tax and payroll rules vary by state and change over time, and this article is not tax advice. Check your own situation with a tax professional who knows your states.

Where does the money hide?

Some sector-specific wrinkles. The account-manager commissions I have seen are often calculated on revenue rather than margin, which rewards selling low-margin licenses. Some providers serve schools and libraries funded through the federal E-rate program, where payment depends on paperwork filed with a third party. Receivables there can sit open for months for reasons that have nothing to do with the client’s willingness to pay.

The common thread is that the information needed to run an MSP well already exists, scattered across the PSA, the distributor portals, the payroll system and the accounting software. What is usually missing is the connective tissue: a chart of accounts that separates the three businesses, a close process that dates revenue by service period, a monthly match of cost to revenue by agreement, and someone responsible for the tax calendar.

Nobody has to buy new software for this. The provider has to keep its own books with the discipline it promises for its clients’ servers. Most MSPs would never tolerate a backup that had not been tested. A margin that has not been tested is the same sort of risk.